James Scott Bell’s Advice to New Novelists: Take Six Novels Apart, Scene by Scene

November 21, 2026

Thriller writer James Scott Bell advises new novelists to choose about six novels of the kind they want to write. When he tried the exercise early in his career, he went to a used bookstore and came home with an armload of paperback thrillers. His first assignment was to read them for pleasure. The index cards came later.

Bell set out the exercise in Plot & Structure, published by Writer’s Digest Books in 2004. He returned to it in the 2012 edition of Revision and Self-Editing for Publication. The idea is to study a plot closely enough that you can replay a whole novel in your head, scene by scene. Plot & Structure · A recap of the exercise

Learning to plot

As a college student in a writing class taught by Raymond Carver, Bell compared his stories with Carver’s and decided he didn’t have what it took. He had come to believe what he later called the “Big Lie,” the idea that writing could never be taught. In his twenties, he gave up on fiction and went to law school.

At 34, Bell started studying craft. Two of his first purchases were Lawrence Block’s Writing the Novel and a screenwriting book by Syd Field. As he tried what he was reading, his writing began to improve. He went on to publish fiction, teach writing, and become the fiction columnist for Writer’s Digest. He wrote Plot & Structure with his younger self in mind. Bell’s account on the Kill Zone

One card for every scene

Bell suggests allowing eight to twelve weeks for the exercise. Start by reading all six books. After each one, take a day to think about your experience as a reader. Which characters stayed with you? Where did the story drag? Jot down your impressions before you move on to the next novel.

Then return to the first novel. Give every scene its own numbered index card. A chapter with three scenes gets three cards. In Plot & Structure, Bell asks writers to record the following details.

  • Where the scene takes place
  • Whose point of view it follows
  • What happens, in a line or two
  • What kind of scene it is, such as action, reaction, or setup
  • Whether the ending makes you want to read on, and why

Repeat the process for the other five novels, keeping one stack per book. Then pick up a stack and flip through it quickly. Bell likens the effect to watching a film in your head. In the original exercise, he adds one more pass. Lay the cards out in order, divide the story into three acts, and look for the scenes that carry it from one act into the next. Keep the stacks so you can return to them.

What writers found in the cards

Cher Green described the exercise on her blog in 2009, down to the two-line summaries on the cards and the sorting of the finished stack into acts. Gwen Hernandez reported getting about halfway through one book before putting the cards aside. A reader commenting on Bell’s blog in 2014 went through ten novels and credited the exercise with helping him understand how stories flow. Green’s account · Hernandez’s account · The discussion on Bell’s blog

In a 2016 interview, Bell described a way to extend that kind of study to character, dialogue, voice, or theme. Pick one element of fiction, read about it in a craft book, find novelists who handle it well, and practice what you learn. With the scene cards, the question that brings those two kinds of reading together is one any reader can answer. When you reached the end of this scene, what made you turn the page?

Bell’s interview with the Insecure Writer’s Support Group