Marguerite Sheffer on Why Writers Need Practice Making Choices

November 21, 2026

Fiction writer Marguerite Sheffer told participants in a November 12 Writer’s Digest University webinar that craft is “all those choices you make to actively shape the story.” Point of view, tense, dialogue, and pacing are among the tools writers use to direct attention of the reader. Getting better at craft, she said, takes practice making choices.

Sheffer put that idea to work in “Getting Your Hands Dirty: Craft Challenges to Level-Up Your Fiction.” She spent much of the 90-minute session leading participants through four timed exercises modeled on published fiction.

Learning to write an ending

When Sheffer began writing seriously, she struggled with writing endings. She started paying attention to how short stories ended, then looked at movies and children’s books. She tried a number of endings in her own fiction. The stories she practiced on became her debut collection, The Man in the Banana Trees. Published by the University of Iowa Press in 2024, it won the Iowa Short Fiction Award and was a finalist for the 2025 PEN/Robert W. Bingham Prize for Debut Short Story Collection.

Sheffer said readers now praise the collection for its endings. Much of what she learned could be found in a craft book, she said. But what made it stick was having to work out how to end a story herself… not following rules in a craft book.

Dialogue was another matter. Sheffer said she wrote and published a book while finding ways around dialogue because she was afraid to write it. She recognized that habit as avoidance. She feels most in charge of her craft, she said, when she chooses to try something that scares her a little.

Practicing with a mentor text

A former high school teacher, Sheffer teaches design thinking and speculative fiction at Tulane University. She drew on her work in design thinking to explain why an exercise can be worth doing even when the result is a mess. She showed participants Damien Newman’s design squiggle, a line that loops back on itself. Writing something new involves some of the same doubling back, she said. A turn that takes a writer away from the eventual story can still teach them something about it.

Sheffer encourages writers to exercise their choice-making abilities by finding model texts to engage with. She favors examples some distance from her own project in genre, subject, or era, and even draws on movies, music, and nonfiction.

Sheffer called this progression “mock, mimic, master,” borrowing a phrase from K–12 teaching. A writer begins by copying a model fairly mechanically, then imitates what the author is doing and eventually adapts it. Sheffer credited that practice of imitating other writers with helping her find her own voice.

Building a craft exercise

Sheffer gave participants five steps for designing an exercise of their own.

  1. Name something in your writing that you’re struggling with or have been finding ways to avoid.
  2. Choose mentor texts that handle it in ways you admire.
  3. Read them as a writer. Identify the choices each author makes.
  4. Keep the text open beside you and try those moves in a short, low-stakes piece.
  5. Reflect on what you learned from trying them.

Sheffer follows the same steps with her writing group on a two-week cycle. She credited several sources for the approach, including Austin Kleon’s Steal Like an Artist.

Sheffer said she had learned plenty from craft books. The difficulty comes in the middle of a draft, when a rule can sound wise and still leave you wondering what to do. Give her a rule, she said, and she’ll think of an award-winning book that breaks it. Exercises, rather than rules, give the writer a chance to try craft in a way that builds mastery more deeply.

Source reporting draws on Sheffer’s Writer’s Digest University webinar.

Sheffer’s event listing · Tulane University author profile · University of Iowa Press book page